Why your offer's terms matter as much as price
Over the years, I have represented numerous buyers who are looking for the perfect home within their budget. In the current local housing market in the South Bay of Los Angeles overall, we have about 2 months of housing supply. That means that if no new homes came on the market, it would take 2 months for every home currently for sale to go into escrow at the current pace of sales. What does this mean? If you are shopping for a home now or in the next year, please read on.
When buyers think about competing for a home, they usually think about price. Price matters, of course. But when I sit down with sellers to review offers, the conversation is rarely only about the highest number. Sellers want to know which offer is most likely to close on the timeline they need, with the fewest surprises along the way. A slightly lower offer that is very likely to close can look better than a higher offer with open questions.
This is especially true right now. With mortgage rates higher than they were this summer and the stock market less steady, sellers have seen escrows fall apart over financing, appraisals and inspections. A seller who has already been through one failed escrow will weigh certainty heavily the second time.
The good news for buyers is that many of the things that make an offer clean cost little or nothing. They come from preparation, clear communication and understanding what the seller cares about. Below I'll walk through how sellers actually compare offers, the pieces of an offer that matter most, and a few things a clean offer does not mean.
How sellers actually compare offers
When offers come in on a listing, I usually prepare a side-by-side summary for my client. Each offer gets a column, and each row is a term: price, down payment, loan type, deposit, each contingency and its length, close date, and any special requests. The seller looks at the whole page, not just the top line.
Here is a simplified example of two offers on the same Redondo Beach home listed at $3,000,000. These are not real offers, but they are typical of what I see.
| Offer A | Offer B |
Price | $3,050,000 | $3,000,000 |
Down payment | 20% | 30% |
Financing | Preapproval letter | Fully underwritten, lender letter attached |
Initial deposit | 1% | 3% |
Investigation contingency | 17 days | 10 days, buyer reviewed seller's reports before writing |
Appraisal contingency | 17 days | 17 days, buyer will cover a shortfall up to $50,000 |
Loan contingency | 21 days | 17 days |
Close of escrow | 45 days | 30 days, with a free 7-day rent-back for the seller |
Offer A is $50,000 higher. Many sellers would still choose Offer B, and here is why.
Offer B's buyer has a larger down payment and a lender who has already reviewed their income, assets and credit. The chance of the loan falling through is much lower. The larger deposit shows commitment. The shorter investigation period tells the seller this buyer is motivated and ready to move through the escrow process promptly. The willingness to cover part of an appraisal shortfall protects the seller if the appraisal comes in below the offered price. The rent-back gives the seller a week to move after closing, which can be worth a great deal to a family coordinating two moves.
Offer A may well close at the higher price. But it carries more ways for the deal to change after acceptance: a low appraisal that leads to a price renegotiation, an inspection that leads to a large credit request, or a loan that takes longer than expected. Once a seller accepts an offer, the status shows as a pending sale and likely the home won’t be shown to additional buyers. If the buyer cancels a few weeks later, the seller often needs to start over and the timeline to the closing gets extended. Many sellers will give up the potential for a higher sales price to avoid that risk.
The lesson for buyers is that every line on that page is a chance to make your offer stronger. Some of those lines cost money. Many of them cost nothing but preparation and effort on the part of your agent.
Financing that sellers trust
Financing is the single biggest reason escrows cancel, so it is the first thing a seller and their agent look at. A buyer needs to have strong financing with a reliable lender who is an excellent communicator.
Pre-approval and full underwriting are different. A pre-approval usually means a lender has looked at your credit and the information you provided and believes you can qualify. Full underwriting means an underwriter has reviewed your tax returns, pay stubs, bank and brokerage statements, and employment, and has approved the loan subject only to the property itself (the appraisal and title). A letter from a lender confirming full underwriting tells the seller the biggest risk in the deal has already been handled. It takes a week or two of work before you shop and it is worth it.
Show where the money is. Sellers want to see that your down payment and closing costs are available. Proof of funds is usually a recent bank or brokerage statement with account numbers removed. If part of your down payment will come from selling stock, from a vesting event, or from the sale of another home, your agent will need to communicate that with the offer.
Plan for stock-based down payments. Many South Bay buyers work in technology and aerospace and hold much of their savings in company stock. If that describes you, talk with your financial advisor about moving the funds you need for the down payment into cash before you make an offer. A drop in the market during escrow can leave a buyer short of funds at exactly the wrong moment.
Understand the appraisal. The lender will order an appraisal to confirm the home is worth what you are paying. When prices are flat or adjusting, appraisals can come in below the contract price. If that happens, the buyer typically has to bring more cash, renegotiate the price, or cancel under the appraisal contingency. There are a few ways to manage this risk to the seller, such has offering to cover a shortfall up to a set amount.
Choose a lender who answers the phone. Sellers' agents often call the buyer's lender before recommending an offer. A local lender who knows the South Bay, responds quickly and can speak clearly about your file adds real weight to your offer. This has been especially valuable to my clients who have purchased with a VA loan. The lender was able to speak with the seller’s agent to communicate the benefits of the modern-day VA loan and do the integrity of the buyer. We have a list of reputable local lenders that we can introduce to our clients, many of which we have worked with for years.
Contingencies, deposit and timing
A contingency is a condition that lets the buyer cancel without putting their earnest money deposit at risk. Contingencies are an important part of the purchase agreement for the buyer and the seller. A clean offer uses contingencies thoughtfully, which will often requires us to speak with our clients in detail about the timelines they are able to meet during the purchase process.
The three main contingencies. In the standard California purchase agreement, the investigation contingency (inspections and review of disclosures), the appraisal contingency and the loan contingency each have a default time frame, typically 17 days. Shorter contingency periods are attractive to sellers and are more common in a competitive market with multiple offers. These timelines involve third parties like home inspectors, appraisers, and other service providers, all of which need to be taken into account before submitting an offer.
The deposit. Buyers usually put down an initial deposit within three business days of acceptance. In California, for an owner-occupied home of one to four units, the amount a seller can keep if a buyer defaults without a contingency to rely on is capped at 3% of the purchase price under the standard liquidated damages clause. A 3% deposit is common in the South Bay, and a smaller one can stand out to a seller in the wrong way.
The closing date. Sellers often have their own move to coordinate, whether that is another home purchase, a move out of state, or a homeowner moving into a new living situation. An offer that matches the seller's preferred timing removes a real worry. Before we draft our offer, I discuss with the listing agent what timeline and terms the seller is looking for. In a seller’s market, it pays to accommodate the seller’s needs. The ideal transaction is a often give and take for both parties.
The rent-back. Sometimes a seller needs to stay in the home for a short time after closing. Offering a rent-back of a few days to a few weeks, can be the term that helps the seller manage their timing. The lease-back needs to be written carefully, with a clear agreements on terms and costs and it ultimately needs to work for the buyer’s lender and homeowner’s insurance.
Avoid additional buyer contingencies. An offer that depends on the buyer selling another home first is the hardest kind of offer for a seller to accept. If you need to sell before you buy, we will discuss the various strategies on how to make this happen. This is a major topic that is addressed in our initial buyer consultation meeting and often a quality lender has access to programs and options that help the buyer who would otherwise be contingent upon selling their home.
Doing the homework before you write
Although most local property listings do not come with a disclosure package that can be reviewed prior to making an offer, there is plenty of homework that can be done prior to submitting your offer on a property.
Important items to review prior to submitting an offer include homeowners insurance availability, a title report and additional property information available with the city or county government and tax record. Before we prepare an offer, it is important to understand the history of the property and any title or public information.
Being the buyer who is easy to work with
There is a part of every offer that doesn't appear on the side-by-side summary. It is the impression the seller and their agent form about the buyer and the buyer's agent.
When a listing agent reviews offers with a seller, they are also advising on what the transaction process could be like. The seller wants to know that the buyer's agent will respond quickly, that the buyer will proceed with their due diligence promptly, act in good faith and treat the home and the owner with respect. Those judgments are a real part of the decision, even when no one says them out loud.
When you work with us to represent you as a buyer, we do a few simple things make a big difference. Listing agents often thank us for our complete and clean offer packages. This takes attention to detail, expertise and it shows that we are a serious and committed buying team. Our clients recognize that we act as their advocates, in addition to their fiduciary. It is important that we work well as a team. Quick, clear response to the listing agent and the seller build confidence. A buyer's agent who has a good working relationship with the listing agent gives the buyer’s offer a better chance from the start.
You may have heard of buyers writing personal letters to sellers. These have become a thing of the past and we don't recommend them. Letters that share details about a buyer's family or background can raise fair housing concerns and many listing agents advise sellers not to read them. A well-prepared offer speaks more clearly than any letter.
What a clean offer does not mean
I want to be careful here, because "clean" can be misunderstood. A clean offer is not an offer that gives up every protection to win.
It does not mean waiving inspections. Skipping the investigation contingency on a home you haven't had inspected can leave you responsible for expensive problems you never saw. Older homes in particular can have sewer line, foundation, electrical or drainage issues that aren't visible on a showing.
It does not mean stretching past your budget. Covering an appraisal shortfall or removing a loan contingency early only makes sense if you have the cash reserves to handle the outcome
It does not mean rushing. Being prepared lets you act quickly when the right home appears. It doesn't mean you have to decide before you are ready.
Every offer involves trade-offs and my job is to lay them out clearly, explain the risk of each option and help you decide what you are comfortable with. The decision is always yours.
A clean-offer checklist
Here are some key tips that we work on together:
- Work with a reliable and local buying team who knows the market, is proactive and responds quickly. Interview and choose your Realtor and your lender prior to finding the home you love.
- Take the time to meet with your buyer’s agent to understand the process and create your purchase strategy.
- Prepare the documents for your loan pre-approval and even underwriting and have funds ready.
- Read the any available disclosures and seller reports as soon as you receive them.
- Choose your inspector team and schedule your own inspections promptly so you can offer a shorter investigation period with confidence.
- Decide in advance your contingency timelines and whether you can cover an appraisal shortfall
- Review the terms with your agent, based on what matter most to the seller and match them where you can.
- Keep every protection you need and understand the risk of every one you shorten.
- Consider your agent and your lender an important part of your buying team. The better you work together, the more successful your outcome will be.
Preparation is the advantage
Buying a home is one of the biggest decisions most of us will ever make and writing an offer can feel like the most stressful part. It doesn't have to be. Nearly everything that makes an offer strong happens before you write it: the lender conversation, the agent consultation and the relationship with the listing agent and the seller. When the initial work is done, your agent can advocate for you and the offer becomes a clear statement of what you want and why the seller can trust you to follow through.
That is the part of the process I enjoy most with my clients. We prepare together so that when the right home comes available, you can act calmly and confidently. If you are thinking about buying in the next year, I am happy to help you get ready on your timeline, even if you aren't ready to look at homes yet.
-Andrea


